Should I Watch Doctor Who? / How to Begin Watching Doctor Who

Once upon a time, I didn’t watch Doctor Who.  I didn’t know why the blue phonebooth was important and I didn’t know if that garbage can thing with the whisk and plunger was a good guy or a bad guy.  Once upon a time, I was too intimidated to even think about watching Doctor Who.  Then I started a new job and met Theresa!  We became fast friends and the only way I survived my first year teaching was because of her friendship and guidance.  Theresa’s the best.  One of the many things we bonded over was our shared love of Marvel, Star Wars, and all those nerdy corners of pop culture fun.  But I couldn’t discuss one of Theresa’s favorite shows/characters/universes with her – Doctor Who.  Eventually, trusting Theresa and her taste, I jumped into the world of Doctor Who and my life has become better in every way for it!  But you may not know Theresa.  Maybe that’s why you’re here.  Maybe you’re curious if you should watch Doctor Who and/or how you even begin watching Doctor Who but you don’t have Theresa there to help you.  Well, that’s why I’m here.  I hope this short piece helps answer your questions, calm your concerns, and ignites your excitement for Doctor Who in the way being friends with Theresa did for me :D.

Should I watch Doctor Who?

Yes.  Yes you totally should!  Start right now!  Yay!

Are you still reading?  Um, do you need more?  Huh.  Ok, well, first let’s address some of the common concerns people have (like I, myself, once had!) before starting Doctor Who.

Doctor Who Watching 3 (2)

The Thirteenth Doctor (Jodie Whittaker) can appreciate the gravity of all your discerning as she, too, has faced many a great choice she’d had to discern. / Photo Credit – BBC’s Doctor Who

IT FEELS WEIRD NOT WATCHING A SHOW FROM THE BEGINNING BUT I’M NOT INTERESTED IN THE 1960s STUFF.  IS IT CONTINUOUS OR DOES 2005 START A NEW SHOW?

Don’t worry about the stuff from the ‘60s.  It’s (comparatively) weird and slow and super low budget.  Modern Doctor Who connects to the classic show – it’s the same character, same world, same story – but you don’t need to watch any of the old episodes to enjoy the new.  In 2005, Doctor Who started fresh.  If you really love it, you may want to go back and try Classic Doctor Who some time.  But if you’re new to the Doctor, just start in the modern era.

THE SHOW IS TOO LONG.

Doctor Who isn’t as long as you think it is!  It may feel like you’re jumping into a show with 1,000 episodes but, for comparison’s sake, the entire modern run of Doctor Who is less than half of Grey’s Anatomy.  The longest season is only thirteen episodes and the shortest is six, with Christmas and New Year’s specials sprinkled throughout.

I DON’T KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT A SHOW WITH DECADES OF CANON.

You’re in luck!  You can start S1E1 with absolutely no background knowledge and everything is explained as you go! But if you’d feel better going in knowing something, the blue phonebooth is called the TARDIS and it’s the Doctor’s ship which travels through all of time and space.  It’s bigger on the inside!  And it sometimes has its own ideas about where and when they should land.  Also, the Doctor is a Time Lord.  Time Lords look human but are aliens who regenerate whenever they are about to die.  They carry their memories with them in each new regeneration but their physical appearance changes and their personality does, too.  So all the Doctors are the Doctor but they each have their own distinct style and personality.

Doctor Who Watching 4

The Twelfth Doctor (Peter Capaldi), for example, wasn’t a big fan of hugs but his best friend and companion Clara Oswald (Jenna Coleman) eventually won him over. / Photo Credit – BBC’s Doctor Who

IF THEY CAN GO ANYWHERE IN TIME AND SPACE, ISN’T IT OVERWHELMING TO FOLLOW?

Nope! The Doctor always travels with a companion – sometimes more than one.  The companions are always from our current time and from Earth.  So the Doctor’s companions are the lens through which we learn about the Doctor’s world.  No matter where or when they go, the Doctor is always explaining things to their companion so we always know what’s going on, too.  It’s super convenient!

I DON’T KNOW WHERE IT’S STREAMING.

Um, you don’t really need me for this one.  You’re on the internet.  Just google to see where Doctor Who is streaming for you.  But, just to be nice, at the time of this writing, Doctor Who streams in America on HBO Max and fubo TV and it can be rented or purchased on Amazon Instant Video, Google Play, and iTunes.

OK BUT, CONCERNS ASIDE, WHY TRY DOCTOR WHO WHEN IT FEELS EASIER TO TRY ANY OTHER SHOW WITHOUT A DECADE OF “NEW” EPISODES?

No other show does what Doctor Who does! The TARDIS can go anywhere in time and space so one episode they can browse the bazaar on the rings around the planet Akhaten or explore the Fourth Great and Bountiful Human Empire in the year 200,000 and then in the next episode swashbuckle with Robin Hood in Sherwood Forest in 1190 or see the birth of the Civil Rights Movement alongside Rosa Parks in Montgomery, Alabama in 1955 or solve a mystery with Agatha Christie in 1926.  Tonally, there are deep, introspective character studies.  There are (to use Theresa’s phrase) goofy, “cheese-tastic” sci-fi romps.  There are fast paced adventures with a grand cinematic scope as well as quietly creepy tales of well-crafted horror.  There’s love!  There’s loss!  There’s ALL THE FEELS. 

The only limit to the stories told in Doctor Who is the imagination of the writers.  No genre, type of character, or narrative style is off limits.  There really is something for everyone and it all feels authentically connected within the larger world of the show.  With regenerations, each actor puts their own unique spin on the Doctor while each new showrunner brings their own vision, too.  This keeps Doctor Who constantly evolving and always feeling fresh.

Doctor Who Watching 5

The Ninth Doctor (Christopher Eccleston) takes Rose Tyler (Billie Piper) to London in 1869 where they meet Charles Dickens on Christmas Eve! / Photo Credit – BBC’s Doctor Who

More than anything else, though, Doctor Who reminds us how magnificent we are.  So many brilliant shows and movies (The Walking Dead, The Leftovers, Westworld, etc.) shine a light on the dark, violent, and brutal parts of human nature and question whether we can transcend it.  But Doctor Who dares to show us how brilliant and beautiful and important we are while examining how we hold on to that in the face of the most challenging trials.  As goofy as it may sound, watching Doctor Who makes you feel proud to be human.  When the Doctor says, “Do you know, in 900 years of time and space, I’ve never met anyone who wasn’t important” you can’t help but feel seen and worthy yourself.  It’s beautiful! 

Steven Moffat, showrunner from 2009-2017, explains Doctor Who this way, “When they made this particular hero, they didn’t give him a gun — they gave him a screwdriver to fix things.  They didn’t give him a tank or a warship or an X-wing fighter — they gave him a call box from which you can call for help.  And they didn’t give him a superpower or pointy ears or a heat ray — they gave him an extra heart.  They gave him two hearts.  And that’s an extraordinary thing.  There will never come a time when we don’t need a hero like the Doctor.”[1]  

David Tennant, who played the Tenth Doctor, speaks to the importance of the character in his own life saying, “When I was a kid, why the show meant so much to me is the Doctor was the hero but he was never the jock…so the Doctor was someone I could aspire to be.  And he was celebrated because he’s clever, because he’s clever and kind.  And that’s such wonderful things for a character to represent.”[2]    

Doctor Who Watching 6 (2)

The Tenth Doctor (David Tennant) tries to sort out what Carrionite Witches could want with Shakespeare’s Globe Theatre. / Photo Credit – BBC’s Doctor Who

Speaking to a young fan who was a victim of bullying in online Doctor Who forums, Peter Capaldi, the Twelfth Doctor, said, “The essence of Doctor Who is kindness; that is what really is underneath all of this.  This is a person who moves through time and space and history, and all kinds of situations, and reacts to them, ultimately – despite the way the different versions of him may appear – he reacts with kindness.  And that is how everyone involved with Doctor Who should be and how everyone who is a fan of it should be.  If they’re not kind, they’re not receiving the show in the proper way and they’re not really a fan of it.”[3]

Who isn’t made better by a story which brings more kindness into their life?  Doctor Who is as entertaining, thoughtful, and well written as anything I’ve ever seen and, yes, there are so many other amazing shows out there which may feel less intimidating to start.  But no other show sees in us what Doctor Who sees in us nor makes us feel what Doctor Who makes us feel.  Personally, it never fails to raise my spirit and fill my heart.  As our lives and world so often seem to grow ever darker, why wouldn’t you want to spend some time with a hero like the Doctor?

How to begin watching Doctor Who

Given Doctor Who’s ever-changing narrative, Doctors, and showrunners, there are several places you can start!

1) “Rose” (S1E1) – this is the pilot of the modern incarnation of Doctor Who.  I (as well as Theresa!) would suggest you begin here with Christopher Eccleston’s Ninth Doctor and Billie Piper as his companion, Rose.  This era features Russell T Davies as showrunner who excels at intimate, character-driven stories.

2)  “Smith and Jones” (S3E1) – this is the only option on the list that comes within a showrunner’s tenure.  Russell T Davies is still at the helm but this stars David Tennant’s Doctor with Freema Agyeman’s Martha Jones.  You may feel a bit lost as this comes in the middle of the Tenth Doctor’s story but you can learn it all through Martha’s eyes.

3)  “The Eleventh Hour” (S5E1) – this stars Matt Smith’s Eleventh Doctor alongside Karen Gillan’s Amy Pond.  The era features Steven Moffatt as showrunner who gives Doctor Who‘s stories a more grand, cinematic feel while writing the best speeches for the Doctor.

4)  “The Woman Who Fell To Earth” (S11E1) – Jodie Whittaker takes over as the Doctor alongside Mandip Gill’s Yazmin Khan, Tosin Cole’s Ryan Sinclair, and Bradley Walsh’s Graham O’Brien.  With Chris Chibnall as showrunner, we get some of the best historical episodes Doctor Who’s ever had as well as a greater sense of family in the larger TARDIS team.

But if this still feels like too much of a commitment or you’re too hesitant to try picking up at the beginning of a season, I have another suggestion.  Watch “Vincent and the Doctor” (S5E10).  Just that episode.  If you were to give me just one single episode to show you the beauty, fun, and excitement Doctor Who holds and how it can move your heart and soul, I’d have you watch “Vincent and the Doctor.”  Then, once you’re hooked, you can circle back and chose one of the above starting points!

Doctor Who Watching 7

Vincent Van Gogh meets Amy Pond (Karen Gillan) and the Eleventh Doctor (Matt Smith). / Photo Credit – BBC’s Doctor Who

Don’t feel you need to binge-watch this show either.  You certainly can, if you get hooked and want to!  But Doctor Who is a show that can sometimes have a year or more between new seasons.  It’s a show best consumed at your own pace.  It feels “wrong” (or at least counter-cultural) to approach a show like this anymore but watch when you want to and take breaks when you want to, too.  You’ll enjoy the show more if you don’t put yourself under any pressure to “get through it” or “catch-up” to the new episodes.  The Doctor will always be there waiting when you’re ready ;).

Lastly, I’ll add this.  When you begin, the show feels unlike anything you’ve ever seen before.  So give it a chance.  Learn the rhythm.  Some people fall in love with it immediately!  For some, it takes a few episodes before it grabs you.  But of everyone in my life who has followed me into the world of Doctor Who, just as I followed Theresa all those years ago, no one has been disappointed.  Everyone has been surprised to find the show is even better than I said it was. I’m sure you’ll love it, too!  Otherwise, I’d not be writing this piece :).

Doctor Who has brought so much fun, excitement, beauty, light, and hope into my life.  On a personal note, I couldn’t’ve gotten through the last year (with the pandemic, lockdown, and some deeply personal losses and struggles) without Doctor Who.  It is a gift.  It’s a gift that has filled my life up and it’s a gift I love sharing!  It offers many ways to experience the show and, should you find yourself loving it as much as I do, it is the ultimate comfort show because it feels like it’s never-ending!  You have the modern run of the show to watch and rewatch.  You have all the seasons from ’63-’89.  You have novels and comics and audio dramas, too.  You needn’t ever experience any of those other stories to enjoy watching Doctor Who.  But, if you’re like me and you find comfort in a show you can return to again and again, then you’ll not find a better choice than Doctor Who.

You’ll not find any show more worthy of your time, either.  And if I still haven’t quite convinced you to trust me on this, that’s ok.  But you can trust Theresa!  She’s the best and she’s not gonna mislead you here.  I know from experience :).  So why don’t you give Doctor Who a try?  As the Thirteenth Doctor reminds us, “None of us know for sure what’s out there.  That’s why we keep looking.  Keep your faith.  Travel hopefully.  The universe will surprise you, constantly.”  And there is a wonderful world waiting for you, full of hope and surprises, with Doctor Who!

Also, Happy Doctor Who Day!  This piece was originally posted on November 23rd 2021, which is the 58th Anniversary of Doctor Who’s very first episode which aired November 23, 1963.  So that’s one more reason to jump on board with Doctor Who!  You get a new holiday to celebrate!

Doctor Who Watching 8

Yaz (Mandip Gill) and the Thirteenth Doctor (Jodie Whittaker) investigate would-be witches in the early 17th century. / Photo Credit – BBC’s Doctor Who

Also, the photo credit for this post’s fantastic featured image is the modern Doctors section of Jeremy Enecio’s character portraits of all Fourteen Doctors, which the BBC released in November of 2019. If you would like to explore Jeremy Enecio’s own site to see more of his amazing work, you can click here, too.

If you’re still curious and/or would like to read more about Doctor Who (with pieces all featuring spoilers of various kinds for the episodes they discuss), you can try one of these pieces:

A Doctor of Kindness: Doctor Who and a Universal Ethic is my loving and detailed examination of how the Doctor moves through the universe and why they do what they do.

Doctor Who, “Can You Hear Me?,” and the Nightmares of (More) Pandemic Teaching looks at how the Doctor has been invaluable in helping me survive the long, tiring struggle of my job while also examining how vitally important it is for all of us to be heard.

“Fancy a Trip in the Box?” – Considering the TARDIS and Each Companion’s First Trip breaks down how the TARDIS operates in more detail as well as giving a super short summary of each companion’s first trip in the TARDIS from Rose up to the present.

The Abject Horror of Doctor Who‘s Confession Dial considers what is, to my mind, the scariest episode of Doctor Who EVER and uses the episode as a springboard to explore what I fear most.


[1] Mark Brake, The Science of Doctor Who: The Scientific Facts Behind the Time Warps and Space Travels of the Doctor, (New York: Simon & Schuster, 2021).

[2] “Jodie Whittaker and David Tennant: Doctors Stick Together.” The Late, Late Show with James Corden, season 2020, episode 783, June 18, 2020.

[3] “Peter Capaldi had this to say to the cyberbullies targeting a Doctor Who fan,” RadioTimes, Published April 11, 2017.  Accessed May 1, 2021.  https://www.radiotimes.com/tv/sci-fi/peter-capaldi-had-this-to-say-to-the-cyberbullies-targeting-a-doctor-who-fan/

13 thoughts on “Should I Watch Doctor Who? / How to Begin Watching Doctor Who

  1. Such a wonderful post! I think I was maybe lucky in that I had no idea what Doctor Who was when I first started watching it. I just happened to see it on television one day and I stopped to watch for some reason and then instead of walking away after a moment, I stayed to watch the whole episode. Even though I didn’t really know what was happening or who the Doctor was or that this was actually a very famous show that had started decades ago. Maybe if I had known the history, I would have been much more intimidated! But instead I thought, “Wow, this is good. I should watch more!”

    And you hit on so many of the points that make the show wonderful! I really do love that the Doctor can can go anywhere and do anything. I love that one episode might be like a mini horror film and the next one is a cheesy sci-fi adventure and then the next one is a love letter to a famous author.

    And–yes to the Doctor being a kind hero! A lot of modern heroes seem to be gray characters, the ones who have to make the hard choices and end up doing horrible things in an attempt to keep control or save their country or whatever. The Doctor does have to make hard choices, but no excuses are made and it’s never really presented as something like, “Well, lots of people will get hurt here, but X Nation is obviously my priority so what will be will be.” It’s always something where the Doctor wants to save EVERYONE, but doing so doesn’t seem possible. No one is seen as more important or more worthy of being saved than someone else just because of where they live or what titles they hold. As the Doctor says–everyone is important.

    And I so agree! The Doctor makes you feel proud of being human. And like you have to live up to the Doctor’s vision of what humanity can be at its best.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. What a wonderful (and unique!) way to come into the world of Doctor Who. I can only imagine what it would be like to find it with no prior knowledge of even it’s place in pop culture history. What a great story, too :).

      I love your frame of contrasting the Doctor with the gray characters we have. I think about that often in regard to our weird cultural fascination with the “antihero.” We seem drawn to create and consume so many of these kinds of characters and, while they have their place and can be entertaining and instructive, I think there is so much more to us and our stories than that. Yet, of late, they seem to be our guiding light narratively. I wonder, too, (not that we can speak in reductive, sweeping generalities with any sense of accuracy) what role that plays in the heaviness of our culture? Does all the time we spend watching, rooting for, and reflecting on these gray characters shape, unconsciously, what we believe we’re capable of? Does it affect our view of the world? I’m sure it does, in some way. That’s the power of a story! But I don’t know how much. Regardless of any sort of effect that may exist there, I agree with Steven Moffat – there will never come a time we don’t need a hero like the Doctor :).

      And YES! You’re so right! The Doctor does call/inspire us to live up to their vision of what we can be! I think that’s part of why the show rings in our hearts so much. We see our potential through the Doctor’s eyes and then we feel called and empowered (and able!) to live that out.

      Like

  2. Starting a new franchise can always be daunting, so this an excellent primer on how to slowly work yourself in without feeling overwhelmed. And thats how I feel about encouraging others to try Star Trek! I saw two immediate parallels between both series- don’t worry about the stuff from the 60’s (TOS), instead start with more modern adaptations, plus one of the aliens in the ST universe are Trills who “… had personalities which were a synthesis of the two beings including the memories, skills, and personalities of the previous hosts” although their humanoid bodies change every generation. I look forward to the challenge you mentioned to me before- where we both watch a few recommended episodes of each other’s favorite fandoms!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. I’ve often presumed there would be lots of parallels between Doctor Who and Star Trek so it’s exciting to know you to see some parallels just from this piece! And WOW, the Trill thing is kinda blowing my mind.

      I’m excited, too! Not only will it be a reason for me to finally jump into Star Trek and hold myself accountable for doing so but it feels like it also kicks our friendship up another notch or two which is pretty awesome. I predict great times will be had by all :D.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. What about Capaldi as a starting point? I think they could have done MUCH better with his version, but leaving him out just feels wrong.

    My doctor is David Tennant.

    My ex loved Doctor who as a child with a baker and the scarf. I saw a few episodes but don’t remember them. They were what my mother put in when my sister was screaming with colic and no one could sleep.

    New Who came on and he watched. I tormented him ceaselessly. I wouldn’t let up and I wouldn’t give him a break. The hero of the story was literally being chased by trashcans, clunking metal men and evil Santa’s. Like, seriously? So I tortured him. Never paying attention to the show just tormenting him. Of course I didn’t do this the whole time. The first 10 minutes of an episode and then for about 20 minutes after the show ended. In between episodes I totally forgot it even came on.

    My friend came to live with us because we had all of our classes together and we were paired up on everything. So she ended up living here part time. He would watch it and she felt the exact same way I did so we tortured him for the first 10 minutes and then for nearly a half an hour after, promptly forgetting it existed within an hour after the episode went off.

    One day, I don’t remember what episode even, we were in the living room and he came in to watch Doctor Who. We immediately started tormenting him. He kept it on pause knowing the routine. He would start it over again and we just started with it. Always. 10 minutes before we got bored and did something else. This time it was 15. And the tormenting got less and less from both of us over the course of that time. By the 15 minute mark we were both watching David Tennant be the Doctor. Even after school ended, she would come over on Saturdays to watch it. Until Matt Smith. We both had an amazingly strong reacting to his Doctor. I will admit, he had some amazing scenes in that first episode, but I couldn’t stand him. Actually, hate is a better word. I hated him. She hated him even more and she stopped watching entirely. I did not.

    I couldn’t understand why I hated him. I was truly perplexed. My ex just always laughed at me and told me “he’s not your doctor. You didn’t sign up for your doctor to go away. Everyone goes through this. It gets easier.” Honestly, it sounded to me like he was makin stuff up. Not my Doctor. Pfft. Same show! No it wasn’t. Not by a long shot.

    So, I still don’t like Matt Smith’s Doctor. The reason is as my ex said: he’s not my doctor. I LOVED Moffatt as a show runner WAY more than Davies. The entire story arc was just so much more exciting to me. It alighted my imagination to no end. But every single episode I quietly thought “David Tennant would be better in this scene” or episode or whatever. There is absolutely nothing wrong with Matt Smith, and if I came in at him I wouldn’t have any issues. But it is my personal opinion that DT was THE best Doctor, and I’ve watched all of New Who and some of the old ones.

    That aside, I will say Moffat was the best show runner with the best stories. Davies was second because this current guy is not good, imho.

    Doctor ranking: DT, PC, MS, CE, JW. I think JW is getting g the short end of the stick because her show runner is working extra hard at making all of her episodes WAY too preachy. I also think that PC was under utilized in favor of Clara. At one point it became the Clara show featuring the Doctor (Danny Pink anyone?). They gave her about 12 great exits. She should have taken them. When she finally did, we got Bill and Missy, and that was totally worth it! Although, Time L-rd Victorious will always be my favorite, and John Simm (spoilers so I won’t say more) is my favorite of that character.

    And I can pretty much recite almost every episode of new who now. Once you’re in, you’re in. However they get you lol

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Thank you so much for saying this because I love Peter Capaldi, too! In fact, when I think of the speeches in ‘Doctor Who’ which really move me the most – the ones that I turn to for inspiration or when I’m sad or to bring myself joy, the ones which touch my heart most deeply – the Twelfth Doctor is without question at the top of the list for me, with Jodie Whittaker’s Thirteen a very close second. But I struggled with any Peter Capaldi seasons as an entry point for someone who’s never seen the show before. I spent a lot of time trying to figure that out XD. S8 throws us right in the middle of everything with Clara and all that happened between her and the Eleventh Doctor. Then S9 begins with Missy and her relationship with the Doctor and Clara. S10 could work as Moffat even titles the first episode “Pilot” and we learn everything with Bill there. But it makes me sad to think someone would just meet the Twelfth Doctor and then he’d regenerate. But that happens with the Ninth so…

      I really appreciate your saying this, though, as I struggled with not including him, too. Maybe I should revisit S10 as an entry point…

      Thank you, too, for sharing your Doctor Who journey with me! I think that’s such a special experience, the hows and whys that bring someone to this wonderful world. I loved yours, too :). And your last line! “Once you’re in, you’re in. However they get you lol” captures how Doctor Who works on your heart and soul perfectly :).

      I remember reading once David Tennant wasn’t completely sure whether or not he was REALLY ready to leave at S4. So Moffat had a version of S5 with David Tennant and Karen Gillan, where he travels around with her, regenerates, but then the Eleventh Doctor lands in her garden when she’s a child. So Amy remains “the first face this face saw” but the Tenth Doctor meets her first when she’s an adult while she remembers meeting the Eleventh Doctor first as a kid. Anyway, all that timey-wimey stuff aside, it is intriguing to think what it would’ve been like to see the Tenth Doctor, Amy, and Rory running through the universe together.

      Like

  4. Actually, you sort of can. The first episode that…omg! I can’t remember his name. The author….um…Gaiman – Neil Gaiman wrote was “The Doctor’s Wife,” which is easily one of my favorite episodes. If you watch it closely, and pay attention, it doesn’t FEEL like a Matt Smith episode. It’s incongruent with the rest of his tenure. But the episode feels SO right. The reason is that Gaiman wrote it specifically for DT to play it. Then we got MS. The truth is, that was the episode that shut me up on MS. Like I said, I don’t have any issue with his doctor (I actually like it back on repeats), but at the time (at least the first season), he was so inherently NOT my doctor that I hated him. They had to make the character different, not just his appearance, and there was nothing resembling my doctor there. But in that episode, MS basically plays DT’s doctor, and it was the first time I didn’t absolutely hate him. It was strange to see a new face but it was my doctor – if that makes sense, even though it was the same face i had already been watching for a while, but it was MY doctor himself that came back through MS. I dunno. Hard to understand for anyone not inside my loopy brain.

    I read that about DT too. I also read somewhere that he had decided he was definitely going to go, it was all announced and everything. The last scene that they filmed (I believe at his request) was the regeneration scene. When he said “I don’t want to go” he was actually saying it out loud, and it felt the way it did because he was really feeling that. That’s why he asked for it to be the last scene. He wanted it to be the last scene for him and the audience together, and that line was supposedly unscripted.

    PC’s speeches didn’t really move me to the extent that you described (I have always preferred a good villain – and Time L-rd Victorious was PERFECT for that). I just really liked him, his version, the essence of that Doctor. I felt it was truly wasted and unfairly so. Just as I feel like JW is being wasted now in favor of the “the fam” and preachy episodes. They’ve managed to create a Doctor who is a caricature of what the Doctor has been for almost 60 years (and honestly, the doctor, especially in New Who IS a caricature already). She is a very talented actress, and she could have brought so much to the character, but he has rested on “she’s the first woman!” and “look! Lots of companions!” and “I have something to say that has nothing to do with the Whoverse, I just want to get into current events”. Not entertaining IMHO. In many ways, there aren’t a whole lot of episodes of JW tenure that are going to stand up to the test of time. You’re going to watch it in 10 years and it will feel dated, boring, and just like a massive departure from canon for no real reason. Sometimes I wonder if Chibnall has actually ever watched Doctor Who before he decided he wanted to work on it. Honestly, it feels like the only reason it is Doctor Who and not another show entirely with the same title is that the actors have seen the show before and try to keep the ambiance the same within the scripts and direction.

    I always felt terrible for PC’s Doctor. I KNOW he was a gigantic fan of DW growing up, and probably the biggest fan boy that was EVER the Doctor (and I know DT was a huge fanboy too). He finally got to be the Doctor and they basically wrote it so that he was a secondary character in his own show, and in every single episode. It started very lightly toward the end of MS – it started getting away from being a show about the Doctor and the person he drags along and became Clara and the dude in the box. Right after she jumped into the timeline. But it wasn’t overwhelming yet. Then, PC comes in with a huge bang talking about the color of his kidneys (I think it was his kidneys, I just remember laughing for about 5 minutes. Then the “cross” eyebrows had me in stitches for a while too). Then, he has to wait while she gets a personal phone call from the previous doctor telling her not to freak out and to be nice and to not destroy the show. How many companions before that had suddenly watched their doctor disappear? Not one of them needed personalized notices to calm down and not freak out. Why they wasted about 5 minutes on that was beyond me. When a doctor throws his arms out and goes all golden, that’s his last scene. He doesn’t get to come back in a timey-wimey way (basically crossing the streams) just because she might run down the street. He’s the Doctor – he can find a new companion by sitting still and watching paint dry. But it set the stage for what was to come. It was about appeasing her, coddling her, and somehow infantilizing PC’s doctor to the point of idiocy. He can’t function without her? He has to work as a janitor just to keep near her? I’m supposed to care that she goes out for a jog and then goes to meet the doctor in a broom closet? I don’t. If you think about it, we never had to sit through any of that with previous companions – and the only reason we ever did with her during MS was because there was the episode that introduced the idea of the woman in the shop, the wifi virus thing, and when they drugged her with the candle LOL But suddenly, the Doctor and companion were not on Earth in that time and spot because there was something to do – they were there because the companion wanted to have a job and a boyfriend. Ick.

    Honestly, I loved Missy – I truly loved her. She was the perfect counter-balance to the Doctor in every way. Somehow they took the teeth out of that character too to play third fiddle to Clara then the Doctor. I would love to get Moffatt, lock him in a room with me and grill him as to what in the world he was thinking. He changed the show so much because of her, the feel of it, the flow of it, that it allowed for the whole Chibnall mess. The first female Doctor deserved so much better than what she got. So did we.

    I’m not sure what I was aiming for in the beginning of this comment lol. Doctor Who is one of those topics I could go on forever and a day.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. By the way, I kind of comment the way that I talk – a lot and randomly LOL and I also tend to think in the comments as I would during conversation – because I will NEVER look it up if I know I know the answer LOL

      Liked by 1 person

    2. Me, too! Even when I’m not talking or writing about ‘Doctor Who’ I’m often thinking of it. So I absolutely get where you’re coming from! In fact, I may put your final two sentences on a t-shirt because it summarizes so many of my discussions about the Doctor XD. You get me! I have a few friends I could give a shirt like that to as well.

      You’ve kind of blown my mind, too. For whatever reason, I’ve never “seen” David Tennant’s Doctor in “The Doctor’s Wife” in the way you’re describing here. But I’m remembering the show in my head as I write now and I think you’re right! I will be rewatching that episode soon with your vantage point in my mind. I remember reading that Neil Gaiman had written it for David Tennant’s Doctor but I’d never watched it with that in mind. Now I’m excited to go back and watch it again! Any excuse to watch more ‘Doctor Who’ is welcome :D.

      I remember reading, too, that Peter Capaldi had visions of making his Doctor more cross/stern/antisocial like the earlier incarnations of the Doctor were. But I guess people – the fans? Moffatt? the BBD? all of the above? – didn’t react well to it so they made him softer, more of a “cosmic imp,” if I recall Capaldi’s quote correctly. It would’ve been interesting to see how he originally intended to develop his version of the Doctor.

      I want to keep replying but I think I need to go watch “The Doctor’s Wife” now…

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s